| Name | Term |
|---|---|
| Mayor Susan Coleman | 2023-Present |
| Mayor Greg Mahler | 2017-2022 |
| Mayor Jim Gourley | 2013-2016 |
| Mayor Craig S. Fentiman | 2004-2012 |
| Mayor Tim McQueary | 2003 |
| Mayor Craig S. Fentiman | 2001-2002 |
| Mayor Tim McQueary | 1999-2000 |
| Mayor Jim Gourley | 1997-1998 |
| Mayor Robert Whitfield | 1995-1996 |
| Mayor Craig S. Fentiman | 1991-1994 |
| Mayor Dave Holley | 1987-1990 |
| Mayor Ruth V. Ganta | 1983-1986 |
| Mayor Robert Harbaugh | 1981-1982 |
| Mayor Robert Hyland | 1979-1980 |
| Mayor Blair Smith | 1977-1978 |
| Mayor Doyle Johnson | 1975-1976 |
| Mayor Ed Buhn | 1971-1974 |
| Mayor Frank Kikel | 1967-1971 |
| Mayor Gerald Wooley | 1965-1966 |
| Mayor William F. Penney | 1957-1964 |
| Mayor William Heseman | 1955-1957 |
| Mayor Eugene Ellis | 1951-1954 |
| Mayor Ed R. Cardwell | 1949-1951 |
| Mayor L.R. Davidson | 1947-1948 |
| Mayor Ivan K. Hoy | 1944-1946 |
| Mayor Stewart Weiss | 1942-1944 |
| Mayor William L. Sneddon | 1942 |
| Mayor Orthor J. Scott | 1941-1942 |
| Mayor Max M. Landon | 1939-1940 |
| Mayor John F. McGlothern | 1938 |
| Mayor John Russell | 1936-1938 |
| Mayor G. H. Crusen | 1934-1936 |
| Mayor Harry Haven | 1931-1934 |
| Mayor Lettie P. Sankey | 1929-1930 |
| Mayor Ernst Scholl | 1927-1929 |
| Mayor Perry (P.E.) Casebeer | 1925-1927 |
| Mayor Everett V. Smith | 1923-1924 |
| Mayor Henry J. Schenk | 1920-1922 |
| Mayor Richard C. Watkins | 1919-1920 |
| Mayor Roscoe W. Van Fleet | 1916-1919 |
| Mayor Henry Myers | 1913-1916 |
| Mayor John McMaster | 1912-1913 |
| Mayor N.R. Luther | 1910-1911 |
| Mayor Mounts Story | 1909-1910 |
| Mayor J.C. Wilkins | 1908-1909 |
| Mayor Mounts Story | 1908 |